How much will solar panels cost you?

Provide a valid 5 digit U.S. zipcode

Subscribe to Our Blog

BIPV Solar Tiles Pass Testing, But are They Ready for Your Roof?

This time last year I wrote about the introduction of a new breed of building-integrated photovoltaics (BIPV): the Solé Power Tile. This unique midnight-blue roofing tile is the first-ever solar product specifically designed for curved roofing systems, according to its manufacturer, SRS Energy. The PV tile is not designed to mount onto a roof, but to seamlessly incorporate into it, creating clean solar electricity while maintaining the home’s overall aesthetic.

sole tile rooftop

All PV products must go through testing by Underwriters Laboratories (UL) to prove their ability for reliable performance. This is especially important in California, where solar products must be UL-listed to qualify for state rebates. The Solé Power Tile recently passed UL testing, which, considering that it is meant to integrate into curved clay tile roofs very common to sunny California, opens it up to a whole new market and millions of potential rooftops.

SRS Energy even partnered with US Tile, the largest manufacture of clay roof tiles in the U.S., to ensure seamless integration. US Tile designed a non-solar tile that matches the relatively odd blue color of the Solé Power Tile.

But are these tiles ready for your roof? At only 5 percent conversion efficiency, the Solé tiles at their best stand far below the average rooftop solar panel. Therefore, they require a lot more space and product to produce the same amount of solar electricity. sole tile solar installationHowever, the plastic tiles are cheaper, ship in bundles and are lighter than traditional clay tiles. Homeowners with a lot of roof space and concerns over aesthetics may be good clients for the Solé Power Tile, but I’m betting this will be a small niche market in the face of other products that are four times as efficient, at least to start.

Also, passing its UL 1703 testing is important for proving that it can perform well, but that still leaves questions about durability. Solar panels will almost certainly be producing energy in 40 years. Can anyone say that about the Solé Power Tile?

Of course, if SRS Energy can get that efficiency up to, say, 10 percent in future product generations, then I think we’ll find a decent amount of people wanting to try them out, which will lead to their being proven in the field.

It should be noted that if there’s any market you want to go into with a fresh, rebate-eligible product, it’s California. There, residents have proven time and time again that they’re willing to lead the way in renewable technology. Perhaps the Solé Power Tile can ride that wave.

Posted on May 20th in Solar Products by .

Related Posts

2 Responses to “BIPV Solar Tiles Pass Testing, But are They Ready for Your Roof?”

  1. ECD Fan Says:

    Dan,

    You were lied to.

    First, SRS Energy’s solar tile is obviously not the first solar product specifically designed for curved roofing systems. Lumeta, for example, has been trying to market their S-tile for quite some time:

    http://www.lumetasolar.com/Pages.aspx/Solar-S-Tile

    Second, the first picture you are showing (the house with blue tiles) is fake. The actual roof has red clay tiles and no tile on that roof generates any electricity. The fraudsters at SRS Energy simply painted the tiles blue in some image-editing software.

    Third, SRS Energy has not passed any UL 1703 test. Period. I will reiterate: SRS Energy is not UL 1703 certified. Not at all. How do I know? SRS Energy is not listed in UL’s or ETL’s database:

    http://database.ul.com/cgi-bin/XYV/template/LISEXT/1FRAME/index.html

    or here:

    http://etlwhidirectory.etlsemko.com/WebClients/ITS/DLP/products.nsf/$$Search?OpenForm

    I urge you to contact ETL and UL and ask them whether SRS Energy has passed UL 1703 testing! Then you will know the truth (I urged Ms. Kraemer to do the same, but she decided to continue to lie to her readers).

    Fourth, the plastic tiles are not cheaper! Plus, there are many reasons why nobody in their right mind will put plastic tiles on a roof (long-term fire hazard, HVAC cost increase due to roof overheating , UL discoloration, thermal deformation and stress, etc, etc).

    Fifth, SRS Energy cannot get to 10% efficiency, as the PV material they are using (Unisolar’s a-Si triple junction PV laminate) has been in production since 1998, and efficiency of the cell has barely improved (the tiles would have been 4% efficient if made in 1998, so all we are talking is about 1% efficiency improvement over 10 years, so for the 5% improvement, we will have to wait 50 years)

    Sixth, as you probably know, there are numerous solar tiles approved for California (see list of all approved modules here: http://www.gosolarcalifornia.ca.gov/equipment/pvmodule.html ) by companies such as Suntech, SunPower, Atlantis, and Sun Energy. Of course, none of those solar tiles have taken any meaningful share from regular panels (sales are basically non-existent), for obvious reasons – cost and underperformance.

  2. ECD Fan Says:

    Ok, as of June 29th, SRS Energy did indeed get their tiles UL1703 certified and on the CEC “approved” list. The top photo in this article is still fake, however.

Leave a Reply